A costly error defined Xavi Simons’ latest appearance for Tottenham, a risky back pass intercepted and swiftly punished by Chelsea’s Moises Caicedo, leading directly to a decisive goal. The incident ignited a firestorm of criticism, casting a harsh light on the £52 million summer signing.
Former Tottenham player Jamie O’Hara didn’t mince words, bluntly comparing Simons’ performance to that of a notorious flop, stating the signing felt like acquiring another Antony – a stinging reference to Manchester United’s expensive and underperforming winger.
O’Hara’s frustration was palpable, describing Simons as consistently giving the ball away with “soft, short” passes. He lamented the player’s impact, suggesting Tottenham were effectively playing with ten men whenever he was on the pitch, a damning indictment for a player of his price tag.
The situation took an even more humiliating turn for Simons when, after being substituted on early due to an injury, he was then substituted *off* again before the final whistle. Manager Frank’s decision underscored a clear lack of faith in the player’s current form.
Chelsea, who had previously pursued Simons themselves, will likely feel vindicated by Tottenham’s struggles. Their near-miss on the transfer now appears to be a fortunate escape from a potentially similar predicament.
Former Chelsea defender Frank Leboeuf offered a particularly blunt assessment, dismissing Simons as a “one-season wonder.” He questioned the expectation that a player with a single standout year could instantly transform a team, labeling those who believed otherwise as “dreamers.”
While Leboeuf’s comments may seem harsh, Simons’ statistics reveal a slight decline in performance. He recorded 19 goal contributions last season, a dip from the 25 he achieved during his breakout campaign with RB Leipzig.
Frank attempted to defend Simons after the match, attributing his early substitution and initial benching to fitness concerns. He highlighted the player’s recent workload, explaining he’d played 90 minutes just days prior and was still building stamina.
However, Frank acknowledged the optics were unfavorable, admitting that being subbed on and off in the same game appeared damaging. He insisted the decision wasn’t a reflection of performance, but rather a strategic move based on physical condition.
Simons now faces an opportunity to redeem himself when Tottenham face Copenhagen in the Champions League. The upcoming match represents a crucial chance to silence his critics and prove his worth to both the club and its demanding fanbase.
