A new Sherlock Holmes has arrived, but this time, the story begins with a surprising twist: a friendship. Amazon Prime Video’s “Young Sherlock” reimagines the iconic detective, played by Hero Fiennes Tiffin, alongside a Moriarty unlike any seen before – a companion, not a nemesis.
For Dónal Finn, inheriting the role of James Moriarty wasn’t intimidating, precisely because it defied expectations. This wasn’t a villain fully formed, but a young man navigating a complex world. The series explores the intellectual equality between the two future adversaries, a dynamic creator Matthew Parkhill describes as “two sides of the same coin.”
Finn readily acknowledges the weight of past portrayals, particularly those of Jared Harris and Andrew Scott. He didn’t attempt to replicate them, but to learn from them. “I found Jared Harris and particularly Andrew Scott…informative for being an actor,” he explains, recalling the boldness and playfulness that inspired him throughout drama school. He even kept a picture of Scott on his wall as a constant reminder.
However, this Moriarty is fundamentally different. While previous iterations showcased a villain already “arrived,” Finn’s James is still “understanding how the world works” and grappling with its inherent injustices. It’s a crucial distinction, one the creators were keenly aware of, determined not to simply present a younger version of Robert Downey Jr.’s swaggering detective.
The series aims for a similar irreverence, but with a fresh perspective. Hero Fiennes Tiffin’s Sherlock isn’t a skilled fighter, a deliberate departure from the action-oriented films. This subtle shift underscores the show’s commitment to forging its own identity.
Max Irons, portraying Mycroft Holmes, faced a similar challenge – honoring the legacy while creating something new. He embraced the idea of learning from predecessors like Mark Gatiss, but ultimately recognized the importance of bringing his own unique energy to the role. “Your DNA…is unique, and that’s the new ingredient in the pot,” he states.
Actress Zine Tseng, as Princess Gulun Shou’an, enjoyed the freedom of a character unbound by expectation. She describes a collaborative, fluid creative process on set, where improvisation and spontaneity were encouraged. Her first day involved a complex monologue delivered in a language she wasn’t fluent in, yet she found herself effortlessly embodying the character’s voice.
Director Guy Ritchie’s sets are renowned for their fast pace and dynamic energy. Irons recalls a thrilling, almost chaotic atmosphere where preparation was paramount. “Guy [is like]: ‘Five, four, three, two, one,’ and if you’re not ready, you’re going,” he laughs, describing the liberating challenge of keeping up with Ritchie’s vision.
The question of the future hangs in the air. Could the deep connection between Sherlock and Moriarty blossom into something more? Finn offers a tantalizingly ambiguous response: “He’s an easy man to love.”
Parkhill hints at further exploration of their complex bond, describing a “Butch Sundance friendship” that blurs the lines between platonic and romantic. He emphasizes that Sherlock will never share a connection quite like this with anyone else.
“Young Sherlock” promises a captivating origin story, a reimagining of a beloved tale that prioritizes character development and emotional depth. It’s a testament to the enduring power of these iconic figures, and a bold new chapter in their legendary rivalry – and perhaps, something more.
