Justice Amy Coney Barrett, speaking at the Federalist Society’s annual convention, offered a poignant reflection on the tragic death of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. She didn’t focus on the act of violence itself, but instead illuminated the remarkable response of Kirk’s wife, Erika, in the aftermath.
Barrett was deeply moved by Erika Kirk’s act of forgiveness towards her husband’s killer. She powerfully articulated that “fighting poison with poison doesn’t work,” and instead, only perpetuates a cycle of negativity and harm.
The Justice urged students to emulate Erika Kirk’s strength and grace, particularly when confronted with hatred. She challenged them to “take the high road,” refusing to succumb to anger or silence in the face of adversity.
The conversation arose from a student’s question about navigating the increasingly charged atmosphere on college campuses following Kirk’s assassination in Utah. Barrett emphasized the importance of continuing to voice convictions, even when facing backlash.
Kirk’s death sent ripples of fear through universities, prompting concerns about a potential rise in political violence. Students and administrators alike expressed anxieties about hosting controversial speakers and fostering open debate.
David Haungs, leader of the Federalist Society chapter at Yale, voiced a sentiment shared by many: the unsettling reality of political violence, especially targeting conservatives in academic settings, weighed heavily on their minds.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh broadened the discussion, acknowledging the pervasive threat landscape facing judges and political figures across the political spectrum. He revealed the alarming frequency of death threats, some of which have resulted in criminal prosecutions.
Kavanaugh recounted the recent sentencing of an individual to eight years in prison for attempting to assassinate him prior to the Dobbs decision. The defendant had traveled across state lines, armed, and ultimately surrendered to police.
In navigating these challenges, Kavanaugh drew strength from the Catholic hymn "Be Not Afraid." He described it as a guiding principle in making difficult decisions, urging the audience to stand firm in their beliefs.
He passionately encouraged listeners to resist peer pressure and pursue what they believe is right, even when facing criticism. These words, he shared, resonate deeply with him throughout his life.
The discussion, moderated by U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden, took place during the Federalist Society’s Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner. Justice Samuel Alito and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche were also present for this significant exchange.
